ALICOM 99/18 ![]() |
Conference on International Food Trade
|
Prospects for the Future:
|
by |
Prof. M. Wahlqvist, Director, International Health and Development Unit and Asia Pacific Health and Nutrition Centre, Monash University |
I. Evidence Based Nutrition and Ecoscience
II. Role of the International Community
III. Food Variety and Human Health
IV. Biodiversity and Human Health
V. Food Variety and Biodiversity
VI. Eco-nutrition Case Studies of Basic Food Commodities
or Ingredients
VIII. Role of Trade in Health Advancement through Food
IX. Food Safety Issues in the Food Chain
X. Food Based Dietary Guidelines (FBDGs)
1. In policy making, project planning and health sciences, there are now strong moves to make decisions and recommendations more robust by marshalling evidence about the complex systems involved. Following on from the implementation of such decisions, monitoring and evaluation with revision of strategies is still required. The kinds of evidence relevant for the broad field of nutrition and eco-science include familiar analytic, observational, experimental and deductive methods of science, with hypothesis formulation and testing. However, with the levels of complexity involved, predictive models, where contributors to the model are well-defined, with various interventions, accompanied by outcome measures, are more likely to be used1.
2. Final decisions about how intrusive of the environment food production for humans can be, will rest on the limits of such evidence and future predictions, and take account of ethical, socio-cultural, economic and political matters28,45.
3. Through international agencies, like the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), World Health Organization (WHO) and World Trade Organization (WTO), it is possible to adduce evidence, make recommendations and set benchmarks in food production for practices which will encourage food security, food of which food safety is part, in the short and long term, which means sustainability. National and local governments have a role to reflect these benchmarks in policy and in regulatory frameworks.
4. Of increasing importance, as the revenue base of governments diminishes, are the roles of the corporate sector and non-government organizations (NGOs) in creating the milieu for sustainability. Local communities, the old and new villages, allow realistic approaches to sustainability to develop.
5. Alliances between the various constituencies of the international community are required to match ecosystem needs. At the same time, a sense of individual identification with an ecological niche will facilitate sustainability - and part of this identification will come from a knowledge of the origins of food. Edward Wilson developed the concept of "biophilia" for a deep biological need for affiliating with life and nature. He identified several values of nature that have to do with human development24 (Table 1).
Table 1. | |||
Value |
Definition |
Function | |
Utilitarian |
Practical and material exploitation of nature |
Physical sustenance/security | |
Naturalistic |
Direct experience and exploration of nature |
Curiosity, discovery, recreation | |
Ecologistic-Scientific |
Systematic study of structure, function and relationship in nature |
Knowledge, understanding, observational skills | |
Aesthetic |
Physical appearance and beauty of nature |
Inspiration, harmony, security | |
Symbolic |
Use of nature for language and thought |
Communication, mental development | |
Dominionistic |
Mastery, physical control, dominance of nature |
Mechanical skills, physical prowess, ability to subdue | |
Humanistic |
Strong emotional attachment and "love" for aspects of nature |
Bonding, sharing, cooperation, companionship | |
Moralistic |
Spiritual reverence and ethical concern for nature |
Order, meaning, kinship, altruism | |
Negativistic |
Fear, aversion, alienation |
Security, protection, safety, awe from nature |
6. The most internationally agreed upon dietary guidelines specify the promotion of breast feeding and the enjoyment of food variety. At the beginning of extra-uterine existence we can depend on one food alone, from one's mother, ideally eating a variety of foods herself, and, thereafter, we explore a widening array of foods, if they are available, and achieve food variety.
7. Simple ways of expressing food variety mathematically (number of biologically distinct foods eaten over a nominated time frame) are now current 18,19,22,23,35,47. Greater food variety in the human diet predicts capacity for survival and reduced morbidity across ethnic groups21,48. More socially active people are more likely to achieve food variety20.
8. The combination of social activity, physical activity and food variety is the most likely lifestyle profile to optimize health, reflected in longevity and healthy ageing49. It is an approach which is also likely to reduce substance abuse. But it is predicated on biodiversity for food variety and environments in which it is a pleasure to be active, both socially and physical.
9. There are several ways in which biodiversity confers health28,50:
10. Seasons and the added diversity they bring also appear to confer vigour. Even where seasons have been regarded as simply `dry' and `wet', as in the tropics, the reality is great change through the solar and lunar years15,24.
11. Food variety is indeed contingent on biodiversity.
12. It is a moot point whether key genetic material for human health can be located in a narrower range of organisms, equivalent to the more biodiverse biomass.
13. One factor determining the required biodiversity, from a food variety point of view, is obviously the extent of required food variety. Available evidence indicates that, with a week as a time frame, at least 20, and probably as many as 30 biologically distinct types of food, with the emphasis on plant food, are required35,47.
14. One of the more intriguing interfaces between biodiversity and food variety is human resistance to infections such as malaria, a parasite that crossed into the human species near its evolution 200 000 years ago, according to the mitochondrial genetic homology studies of Sangkot Marzuki at the Eijkman Institute in Jakarta. A number of genetic changes in red cell metabolism have featured in populations exposed to malaria, notably sickle cell anaemia and various haemoglobinopathies. Glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency limits use of a plant food, broad beans, and is known as favism, but partially protects against malaria. Here a food restriction is required for survival prospects.
15. Some examples of how the food supply may not meet nutritional expectations on account of environmental restraint may be helpful in constructing recommendations about nutritional health and sustainability.
16. It will be evident from the consideration of water and food supply relationships and from the growing appreciation of the range of foods required to optimize health that they must be produced together as far as possible. Methods for successfully doing this are being described as permaculture30,31 and eco-agriculture6.
17. The Australian wine industry has profited in this way following the initial work at Botobolar vineyard in Mudgee, New South Wales with ecological control through and inter-vine cultivation of other plants with their insect population and birds that feed on them44.
18. Post-harvest waste is a major environmental threat because it puts unnecessary strain on food production. It occurs through mishandling and poor management, holding facilities not secure against pests and rodents, unsatisfactory climate control with spoilage and moulds, and inappropriate preservation techniques, and limited transport from site of harvest to food processor. In South-East Asia, as much as 30% of fish harvested is lost to human consumption in this way, and some of the remainder which is eaten is unsafe1.
19. Many areas where food has been produced in the past are now desolate because of desertification, salivation or pollution by accumulated heavy metals from fertilizers (eg. cadmium) or pesticide residues. Prevention of these problems would have been preferred, chief amongst them would have been retention of environmentally intact locales and of trees. But methods of eco-restoration are becoming available. Their support by nutrition and health scientists with a long-term view of their own role in health is crucial. Nutritious food in the short term, at any long-term cost, is not sustainable. Fortunately biodiversity, food variety and health intersect favourably.
20. Various nutrition policies have placed emphasis on local food production for food security and health34. The rationale for this is that, in times of food trade difficulty, there continues to be a local food supply; that knowledge about food and skill in its production are not lost; that local food culture, with its beliefs, habits and checks and balances on intake continues to play a role, even in the evolution towards a more contemporary food culture. Hopefully, food cultural change can be informed by science, health and environmental considerations.
21. Such emphasis on local foods and cuisine is not exclusive of food trade, which, in any case, can be complementary to the local food supply. And, even though humans have migrated far from their original roots, in or around the Rift Valley in Africa, to successfully occupy various environmental niches, many communities and nations are now dependent, to a lesser or greater extent, for their food security on trade. This is especially so where local population size has outstripped local food production capacity and/or water supply, sometimes because food imports have been affordable.
22. Examples of heavy dependence on food trade for survival are island states, desert economies, remote mountainous and icy regions. In the past, communities in these areas were small and seafaring, or nomadic, with highly developed hunting and gathering skills, complemented by subsistence agriculture or animal herding. Indigenous peoples, until recent times, managed their food affairs this way. Trade capability has, in a sense, changed much of that and respectful and consultative review of the situation of such peoples, their food and ecosystems is required.
23. In the case of Pacific Island communities, generally small and far-flung, at the end or on the course of long trading routes, local foods tend to be limited and imported foods expensive. The traditional cuisine which included plentiful seafood, along with coconut, greens and root vegetables, with some birds and their eggs, served remarkably well until early this century. It gives some guidance as to the lower limits of food diversity and the food commodities required at the level of variety. Learning to live healthfully with a rapidly changing imported food supply and its impact on locally produced foods has not been easy. The rises in prevalence of obesity, Non-insulin dependent diabetes (NIDDM) and cardiovascular disease have been dramatic42,43,58,59. Part of the problem has been an associated decline in energy expenditure associated with food gathering in the past.
24. In the case of Singapore on the other island, an island city state, urbanization has brought similar risk. The policy has been to virtually entirely import food, and use food production resources like land to excel technologically and economically. The problems of physical inactivity and obesity have been addressed by political leadership and international policies in schools, the defend forces and the community-at-large. Even then, NIDDM and cardiovascular disease prevalences equal or exceed their earlier industrialized counterpart. These experiences underscore the need for broad health policies to accompany new trade initiatives.
25. There are some geographical locations where there are endemic nutrient deficits, like iodine and selenium, because of soil deficits17; or away from safe water so that nutrients like omega-3 fatty acids are hard to come by40,41; or where certain plants grow with difficulty and their components are not available. Clearly, imported food helps resolve these problems without recourse to food fortification or supplementation, generally a less satisfactory option as it oversimplifies the basic food inadequacy as a nutrient or food component inadequacy.
26. There is also a special situation for large continental nations where a wide range of food can be produced in different climates and food exported in quantity. Such nations have a great international responsibility for sustainable food supplies.
27. Food trade is often stimulated as people migrate with their food cultures. This is particularly evident in culturally pluralistic advanced economies like those of North America and Australasia. There is good circumstantial evidence that the injection of new foods into these locations has contributed to health advancement. Greater emphases on food trade might have spared some of the new precarious ecosystems in these locations - like the rice growing areas of Australia.
28. The limits to food trade from an environmental point of view will be:
i) the import of food export on the ecology of the locale from which food is exported
ii) the non-renewable resource costs of food transport
iii) the impact of food import on local eco-agriculture - in some parts of the world new and sustainable ecosystem have developed around old agricultural practice, with Europe, Africa, Meso- and South America, the Far East and South East Asia all providing such examples. Classically, the bird and insect life changes in relation to crop production.
29. At each step in the food chain, food safety issues can arise. They may be microbiological, physical (filfth), chemical (contaminants, naturally occurring toxicants) or nutritional (changes in food components, or the expectation which a food will serve in a cuisine, be it old, emergent or composite).
30. Risk analysis, management and communication are now required at a greater level of sophistication as environments for food production, food trade increases, new food technologies including biotechnologies emerge, and food cultures evolve.
31. A traditional horticulturalist may use animal manure or human waste as fertilizer, and process the fruit in a way that solves the intrinsic microbiological risks. One who sends his or her fruit to a juice manufacturer may not. There are many such examples, which ecological, food and nutrition literacy may partially address, but for which safety protocols and management will increasingly be required.
32. The FAO and WHO have formulated and promulgated FBDGs, following a Cyprus resolution in 199556.
33. These guidelines take account of the least available food, nutrition and health science and offer an approach whereby communities can take account of and evolve these local food culture and cuisine with this knowledge. They recognize that there is not only one way by which food intake can serve health for a species which is omnivorous. One of the underlying principles which will consistently be applied, however, is that of the value of food variety for humans, with one staple being less satisfactory from health and food security points of view.
34. FBDGs can, therefore, support sustainable approaches to food and human health.
35. Human health patterns are changing in a major way, especially with the advent of life-style related diseases (so-called chronic non-communicable diseases, or CNCD) and will continue to change57.
36. What has been surprising is that there may be communicable elements of so-called CNCD - like H. pylori in upper gastrointestinal disease29 and chlamydia in atherosclerotic vascular disease. The nexus between nutrition, and immune function and infection is pervasive. Also undernutrition, even in pregnancy, and early life may contribute to CNCD2,3,4,5,33. Thus food available throughout life and the role it plays in family health remains important.
37. Changing demography, especially towards ageing population, also affect eco-nutrition thinking. At once, there is an enduring repository of food and health knowledge amongst the aged, whilst they, in their frailty, have special nutritional needs25,54. But the biological potential of older individual is greater than heretofore thought25 as life expectancy increases and compression of morbidity to the end of life becomes more evident. Older people can still engage in the food chain! Population projections are that the world population will stablized in numbers, with about 20% over the age 60s by the year 2020. With such large numbers of older individuals, any sustainable food and health strategy must carefully factor them in.
38. As we seek to finesse human health we look to food to help. Food technological innovation matched with progressive nutrition science will develop new food for this purpose.
39. Yet there will be unexpected new health problems and questions about the role of food and the environment - mood and cognitive disorders, new infections. This is where eco-nutrition will need to be more pro-active.
1. ASEAN Food Conference, Kuala Lumpur, 26-29 July 1994.
2. Barker DJ, Martyn CN, Osmond C, Hales CN, Fall CH. Growth in utero and serum cholesterol concentrations in adult life. BMJ 1993; 307 (6918):1524-27.
3. Barker DJ, Osmond C, Simmonds SJ, Wield GA. The relation of small head circumference and thinness at birth to death from cardiovascular disease in adult life. BMJ 1993; 306(6875):422-426.
4. Barker DJ. Maternal nutrition and cardiovascular disease. Nutr Health 1993; 9(2):99-106.
5. Barker DJ. The intrauterine origins of cardiovascular disease. Acta Paediatr Suppl 1993; 82 suppl 391:93-99.
6. Beaumond H-C and Barnett A. Trade liberalisation and European agriculture: Opportunities and risks for the rural environment. In: Agriculture and world trade liberalisation. Edited by Redclift MR, Lekakis JN and Zanias GP. CABI Publishing, Wallingford, Oxon, UK, 1999, pp 104-118.
7. Burr ML, Fehily AM, Gilbert JF, Rogers S, Holliday RM, Sweetnam PM, Elwood PC, Deadman. Effects of changes in fat, fish and fibre intkes on death and myocardial reinfarction: diet and reinfarction trial (DART). Lancet 30 Sept 1989; 757-761.
8. Charalambous G. Spices, Herbs and Edible Fungi. Elsevier, Amsterdam, Netherlands, 1994.
9. Charnock JS. Dietary fats and cardiac arrhythmia in primates. Nutrition 1994; 10(2):161-169.
10. Charnock JS. The role of omega-3 PUFA enriched diets in the prevention of ventricular fibrillation. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition (in press).
11. de Lorgeril M, Salen P, Martin J-L, Monjaud I, Delaye J and Mamelle N. Mediterranean diet, traditional risk factors, and the rate of cardiovascular complications after myocardial infarction. Final report of the Lyon Diet Heart Study. Circulation 1999; 99:779-785.
12. DeMan JM. Principles of food chemistry. 3rd edition. The Avi Publishing Company Inc. 1980).
13. Duke JA. Handbook of Medicinal Herbs. CRC Press 1989.
14. Economy E. Painting China Green. The next Sino-American Tussle. Foreign Affairs 1999; 78(2):14-18.
15. Flannery T. The future eaters. Melbourne: Reed Books, 1995.
16. Gross R, Karyadi D, Sastroamidjojo and Schultink W. Guidelines for the development of research proposals following a Structured, Holistic Approach for a Research Proposal (SHARP). Food and Nutrition Bulletin 1998; 19(3):268-282.
17. Hetzel BS. The story of iodine deficiency: an international challenge in nutrition. Oxford University Press, 1989.
18. Hodgson JM, Hage B, Wahlqvist ML, Kouris-Blazos A., Lo CS. Development of two food variety scores as measures for the prediction of health outcomes. Proc Nut Soc Aust., 16:62-65, l991.
19. Hodgson JM, Hsu-Hage BH-H & Wahlqvist ML. Food variety as a quantitative descriptor of food intake. Ecology of food and nutrition 1994; 32:137-148.
20. Horwath CC. A random population study of the dietary habits of elderly people. PhD thesis. Department of Community Medicine, Adelaide, 1987.
21. Hsu-Hage B & Wahlqvist ML. Food variety of adult Melbourne Chinese: A case study of a population in transition. IN: Dietary patterns of selected countries, tea and coffee: Metabolic consequences. World Review of Nutrition and Dietetics, Basel, Karger, 1996, vol 79, 53-69.
22. Kant AK, Schatzkin A, Harris TB, Ziegler RG and Block G. Dietary diversity and subsequent mortality in the First National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey Epidemiologic Follow-up Study. Am J Clin Nutr 1993; 57:434-440.
23. Kant AK, Schatzkin A, Ziegler RG. Dietary diversity and subsequent cause-specific mortality in the NHANES I epidemiologic follow-up study. J Am Coll Nutr 1995; 14:233-238.
24. Kellert SR. The value of life. Washington DC: Island Press, 1996.
25. Khaw K-T. Healthy Aging. BMJ 1997; 315:1090-1096.
26. Kushi L, Lew RA, Stare FJ, Ellison CR, Lozy ME, Bowike G, Daly L et al. Diet and 20 year mortality from coronary heart disease. The Ireland-Boston Diet Heart Sutdy. New Eng J Med 1985; 312:811-818.
27. Leaf A. Dietary prevention of coronary heart disease. The Lyon Diet Heart Study. Circulation 1999; 99:733-735.
28. McMichael AJ. Planetary overload. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993.
29. Marshall B. NSAIDs and Helicobacter pylori: therapeutic otpions. The Lancet 1998; 352(9133):1001-1003.
30. Mollison B, Holmgren D. Permaculture one: A perennial agricultural system for human settlements. Tagari Publications, 1990
31. Mollison B. The permaculture book of ferment and human nutriiton. Tagari Pubilcations, 1993.
32. National Nutrition Survey, Australia, 1995
33. Osmond C, Barker DJ, Winter PD, Fall CH, Simmonds SJ. Early growth and death from cardiovascular disease in women. BMJ 1993; 307 (6918):1519-24.
34. Powles J, Wahlqvist M, Robbins J, King C and Hicks N. The development of food and nutrition policy in Australia, with special attention to the state of Victoria. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1992; 1(1): 47-60.
35. Savige GS, Hsu-Hage B & Wahlqvist ML. Food variety as nutritional therapy. Current Therapeutics March 1997; 57-67.
36. Sciarrone SE, Strahan MT, Beilin LJ, Burke V, Rogers P and Rouse IR. Ambulatory blood pressure and heart rate responses to vegetarian meals. J Hypertens 1993; 11(3):277-285.
37. Sciarrone SE, Strahan MT, Beilin LJ, Burke V, Rogers P, Rouse IL. Biochemical and neurohormonal responses to the introduction of a lacto-ovovegetarian diet. J Hypertens 1993; 11(8):849-860.
38. Shetty K and Labbe RG. Food-boren pathogens, health and role of dietary phytochemicals. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1998; 7(3/4): 270-276.
39. Shetty K. Biotechnology to harness the benefits of dietary phenolics; focus on Lamiaceae. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1997; 6(3):162-171.
40. Simopoulos AP, Kifer RR and Wykes AA. Omega 3 fatty acids: research advances and support in the field since June 1985 (worldwide). World Rev Nutr Diet 1991, 66:51-71.
41. Simopoulos AP. The future of fatty acids in human nutrition: health and policy implications. World Rev Nutr Diet 1994; 75:XV-XIX.
42. Swinburn B. Insulin resistance and low metabolic rate: do they cause obesity? Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1995; 4(4): 343-344
43. Swinburn BA, Boyce VL. High-fat diet causes deterioration in glucose tolerance, insulin secretion and insulin action. Diabetes 1989; 38 Suppl 1:376A.
44. Symons M. One continuous picnic: a history of eating in Australia. Duck Press 1982.
45. Tansey G, Worsley T. The Food System. London: Earthscan Publications Ltd., 1995.
46. Wahlqvist A. Out of our depth. The Murray-Darling river system is collapsing under human abuse. Can science save it? The Australian Mazazine, September 13-14, 1997, pp 17-19.
47. Wahlqvist ML, Lo CS & Myers KA. Food variety is associated with less macrovascular disease in those with Type II diabetes and their healthy controls. Journal of American College of Nutrition, 8(6):515-523, 1989.
48. Wahlqvist ML, Kouris-Blazos A & Wattanapenpaiboon N. The significance of eating patterns: A elderly Greek case study. Appetite. (in press)
49. Wahlqvist ML. Health Ageing: A nutritional perspective. Proceedings of the Vietnam-Australia Conference on Health Promotion, Hanoi, 18-20 February 1998: 138-143.
50. Wahlqvist ML & Specht RL. Food variety and biodiversity: Econutrition. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1998; 7(3/4):314-319.
51. Wahlqvist ML & Dalais F. Phytoestrogens - the emerging multi faceted plant compounds. (Editorial) Medical Journal of Australia 1997; 167 (3):119-120.
52. Wahlqvist, M.L., Lo, C.S. and Myers, K.A. Fish intake and arterial wall characteristics in healthy people and diabetic patients. The Lancet, II: 944-946, 1989.
53. Wahlqvist ML. Critical Nutrition Events in Human History. Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1(2): 101-105, 1992.
54. Wahlqvist ML, Hsu-Hage BH-H, Kouris Blazos A, Lukito W, IUNS study investigators. Food Habits in Later Life. A Cross Cultural Study. CD Rom. United Nations University Press and Asia Pacific Journal of Clinical Nutrition 1995.
55. World Cancer Research Fund/American Institute for Cancer Research. Food, nutrition and the prevention of cancer: a global perspective. American Institute for Cancer Research, Washington DC, 1997.
56. World Health Organization (Member: ML Wahlqvist). Preparation and use of food-based dietary guidelines. Report of a Joint FAO/WHO Consultation (1995: Nicosia, Cyprus). World Health Organization, Geneva 1998.
57. World Health Organization. Diet, Nutrition and the Prevention of Chronic Diseases. World Health Organization, Geneva, 1990.
58. Zimmet P, Serjeantson S, Dowse G, Finch C, and Collins V. Diabetes mellitus and cardiovascular disease in developing populations: Hunter-gatherers in the Fast Lane. pp 197-212. IN Sugar in Nutrition. Ed. Michael Gracey, Norman Kretchmer, Ettmore Rossi. Raven Press 1991.
59. Zimmet P. Type 2 (non-insulin-dependent diabetes): an epidemiological overview. Diabetologia 1982; 22:399.